Free Kareem
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Media
  • FAQ
Join Now Campaign Info
Egypt’s Foreign Minister: We reject criticism of Kareem’s case from anyone, “whoever he may be” March 8th, 2007

Shortly after Kareem was sentenced to prison on February 22, the Foreign Minister of Egypt told the world he doesn’t care about the global outrage caused by chasing a harmless blogger: القاهرة تستنكر ردود الأفعال على الحكم بسجن مدون. (Hat tip: Ahmed)

We’ve translated the Arabic Al-Jazeera article:

Cairo Condemns Reactions to Sentencing Blogger to Prison

Ahmed Abul-Gheit considers criticism of Abdul Kareem Suleiman’s sentence as interference in the judiciary system.

PHOTO: Ahmed Abul-Gheit considers criticism of Abdul Kareem Suleiman’s sentence as interference in the judiciary system.

Egypt strongly criticized the reactions to condemning an Egyptian blogger, who owns a Web site, on charges of attacking Islam and President Hosni Mubarak, and to imprisoning him for four years.

Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Abul-Gheit issued a statement rejecting the intervention of anyone, “whoever he may be”, in the work of the Egyptian judiciary, or anyone commenting on its provisions.

Abul-Gheit also said that Egypt rejects the positions of “some media outlets and non-governmental organizations abroad”, expressing Egypt’s “strong displeasure and dismay” for that.

A court in Alexandria, in northern Egypt, sentenced Abdul Kareem Suleiman to four years in prison under the charges of contempt of the Islamic religion and insulting President Mubarak.

The Moharram Bek Misdemeanor Court sentenced the defendant to three years in prison under the charge of contempt of Islam, and one year under the charge of insulting the President. Suleiman was a student at Al-Azhar University, which expelled him last year and demanded having him tried. He is the first Egyptian blogger to be issued a prison sentence.

U.S. State Department deputy spokesman Tom Casey said he is “very concerned” about the prison sentence that was imposed on blogger Abdul Kareem Suleiman for expressing his opinions. In addition, foreign human rights organizations, as well as Egyptian organizations, such as the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists and the Egyptian Organization for Human Rights, have denounced the sentence.

Eight Articles

Suleiman wrote his articles under the pen name Kareem Amer. He was tried because of eight articles that he published on his blog, in which he strongly criticized Al-Azhar University, which he described as a “university of terrorism and spreading extremist ideas”.

Furthermore, in one of these articles, he strongly criticized Mubarak, equating him with “pharaonic dictators”. In another article entitled “The Naked Truth of Islam as I Saw It”, Suleiman talked about the sectarian confrontations that occurred in Alexandria in 2005, accusing it of inciting sedition and tarnishing the image of Muslims.

Held since last November, Suleiman did not deny writing these articles, but he said that they only reflected his personal opinions. The defense team asserted that he would appeal against the sentence, describing the trial as unjust.

Mr. Abul-Gheit is wondering why the outside world seems to be so concerned about the judicial branch of sovereign Egypt.

Albeit being anachronistic, an eloquent response was written by Kareem Amer himself, shortly before his arrest:

I hereby declare, in all frankness and clarity, my rejection and repudiation of any law, any legislation, and any regime that does not respect the individual’s rights and personal freedom, and does not acknowledge the absolute freedom of the individual in doing anything – as long as he does not affect anyone around him in a physical way –, and does not acknowledge the individuals’ absolute freedom in expressing their opinions, whatever they may be and whatever they cover, as long as this opinion is merely an opinion or words coming from a person, and is not coupled with any physical action that harms others. At the same time, I declare, in all clarity, that such laws do not obligate me in any way, and I do not acknowledge them or their existence. I detest, from the depths of my soul, whoever works on implementing them, whoever uses them as a guide, and whoever is satisfied with their existence or benefits from them. And if these laws are forced upon us, and we have no power or strength in changing them because that is in the hands of those in power with agendas, who are more than satisfied for the existence of such laws and are making use of it: Nevertheless, all of this will not push me into submission, or into waiting for relief and appeasement.

I hereby declare that I do not acknowledge the legitimacy of my summons to investigate a matter like this, which is within the realm of my freedom to express my opinions. This freedom was stipulated by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which Egypt has supposedly signed. Moreover, setting this declaration aside, and even if it did not exist, and even if Egypt did not sign it, human rights are very self-evident matters that do not require legislations or laws to regulate them or to define their essence.

UPDATE: (April 11, 2007)
An Italian translation of the article is now available here!

COMMENTS
Posted In: Freedom of speech, Kareem, Press, Translation
Previous
Next
  • Giovanni B.
    Translated in Italian and posted on "www.dalMondo.info". Hope it can help.
    Ciao
  • Koncan
    It is absolutly disturbing to be jailed for expressing an opinion that is shared by many poeple. To try to shut up a differing view is tantamount to nazism, and and we all know what happenned with that attitude. To commit a crime and to say it is on behalf of God is rediculous. By doing so they are saying that God has no power and that they have to do His work. By saying they are working on Dod's behalf also means they do not know God at all.
    Shame is on them that act without knowledge.
  • Voltaire
    Dear Kareem,
    You are in the best tradition of the fighters for Human Rights.
    It is stupid by Egyptian government and "justice" to punish You, because You and Your concern becomes more and more knwon and important to the whole world.
    Thank You, Kareem.
  • Tom G. Palmer
    It reveals a lot that mere criticism is considered "interference" in Egypt's affairs. Do defenders of this terrible mistake want the whole world to shut up? Should censorship be extended to the entire world? I hope that if I am ever wrongly arrested by my government, that people in Egypt would speak up for my rights. How can I do any less for them?
blog comments powered by Disqus
  • Digest
  • Documents
  • Donation process
  • Donations
  • Egyptian blogosphere
  • Freedom of speech
  • General
  • HRINFO
  • Human rights
  • Insulting Islam in Egypt
  • Kareem
  • Letter Campaign
  • Letters
  • Petition
  • Podcast
  • Press
  • Protest
  • Rally info
  • Site info
  • Special occassions
  • Translation
  • United Nations
  • Video
  • Visits
  • Worldwide rallies
Recent Posts
Hundreds of letters for Kareem Urgent request: Flood the Jail with Mail Security officers broke into Kareem’s prison cell, confiscated his letters and destroyed his writings Amnesty UK runs awareness campaign for Kareem Kareem in the news
See All
Get Involved
Write To Kareem Follow Kareem on Twitter
Latest Tweet
No public Twitter messages.
Follow Us On Twitter
© 2010 FreeKareem.org
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Media
  • FAQ
  • Mohamed Fadel Fahmy's report on Kareem
  • Release Jailed Blogger
  • Free Kareem Amer
  • Solidarity Campaign for Kareem
  • Blog Categories
  • Kareem Rallies
  • Kareem in the Press
  • Arab & Muslim Voices For Kareem
  • mideast youth sites
    • Mideast Youth
    • Baha'i Rights
    • Kurdish Rights
    • Migrant Rights
    • Israelis for Palestine
    • MEYcast
    • Mideast Tunes
    • March 18
    • Postcards for Iran
    • شباب الشرق الأوسط
    • جوانان خاورم
  • social networks
  • rallies
  • wordpress
    WordPress Plugin
  • rss
    • RSS for this site
    • RSS for all our sites 
  • mail
    Contact Us
  • facebook
    Our Facebook Group
  • twitter

    @OR318: What does China censor online? http://bit.ly/aDm1c5 #OR318

    29 Jul 2010

    @ifpalestine: Avrum Burg's New party concept (intresting read and critic about Burg new political party) http://fb.me/EhLcmv9Y

    28 Jul 2010

    @ifpalestine: Increased Army Violence During Weekend Demonstrations http://fb.me/DSr3fwlB

    28 Jul 2010
    • Follow Us
    • Follow All
  • notification
    Notifications

    If you run a WordPress blog, don't forget to download the Free Kareem WP Plugin.

    Download it here
    close
  • minimize
    Minimize
toolbar
Maximize